Other Mommy (2026) – Review, Cast, Plot & Trailer

Other Mommy (2026)

A little girl becomes the target of a protean demon that copies her mother’s face and begs entry into her heart, pulling her troubled household toward a confrontation with its deepest dread. Starring Jessica Chastain and Arabella Olivia Clark.

Supernatural Horror • Psychological Horror • 1h 33m • R • 2026

👁️ Full movie link will be available in 15 seconds…
🎬 Watch Full Movie

Other Mommy Review: A Fearless Chastain Versus a Horror Outing Reviewers Refuse to Forgive

Other Mommy sits squarely in that corner of horror that cleaves viewers into opposing camps, and in 2026 few releases have cut so cleanly. Rob Savage (Host, Dashcam) directs from Nathan Elston’s take on Josh Malerman’s Incidents Around the House, with Jessica Chastain front and centre as a career-absorbed mother whose seven-year-old is pursued by a shifting presence wearing her face. Mounted beneath the Blumhouse–Atomic Monster umbrella, the picture takes audacious risks—demons folded under countertops, torsos drawn out to monstrous proportions—and the press has retaliated with some of the harshest write-ups of the season.

Critics Score
19%
Audience Score
D+
Metacritic
38
Worldwide Gross
$85.9M

Those figures capture a movie the reviewers largely buried while paying customers arrived in numbers no one forecast. On Rotten Tomatoes, Other Mommy shows a grim 19% from 93 critics at an average of 4.4/10, with a consensus stating: “Despite a valiant turn from Jessica Chastain as the spectral embodiment of a smothering parent, Other Mommy proves too silly for its intermittently effective jump scares to add up to a spooky whole.” Metacritic recorded 38 out of 100—”generally unfavorable”—and CinemaScore patrons issued a D+, among the most brutal grades given to a wide horror release in recent years. Nevertheless, against an $18–19 million budget it hauled in $85.9 million worldwide, reaffirming that horror stays Hollywood’s most reliable moneymaker.

The critical shellacking was comprehensive. The New York Times‘s Beatrice Loayza dubbed it a “sometimes-creepy, sometimes-hilarious schlockfest,” wondering plainly “What is the other mommy supposed to be?” The Guardian‘s Benjamin Lee granted it 2 out of 5, noting that the movie starts as a “tense, creepy thriller” before sliding into “an increasingly absurd battle with a special effects oogum-boogum that gets less scary as the movie progresses.” Entertainment Weekly recorded that it was “panned as mother of all horror bombs,” with reviewers calling it “more silly than scary” and “excruciating.” Metacritic’s own tally makes the point: across 14 notices, 3 landed positive (21%), 7 mixed (50%), and 4 negative (29%).

Where the critics found consensus was on Chastain. Her paired performance—the emotionally walled-off Ursula and the vicious Other Mommy—drew descriptions like “valiant” and “committed,” the actress plainly savouring the physical extremes of playing a demon. The craft on display, shot in Dublin by cinematographer Lowell A. Meyer with a Patrick Jonsson score, was also acknowledged as polished even where the writing collapsed. Other Mommy may not qualify as a good film by most sensible yardsticks, but it is an engrossing one: a horror entry reaching for psychological texture and settling somewhere between authentically disturbing and accidentally comic. For Chastain completists, or for anyone who enjoys watching a horror movie gamble everything and lose spectacularly, it merits a viewing.

Other Mommy Cast: Jessica Chastain Doubles Up in a Devoted Ensemble

The film fields a capable company anchored by an Oscar winner undertaking some of the most physically punishing work of her career:

Jessica Chastain
Ursula Martin / Other Mommy
Arabella Olivia Clark
Isabela “Bela” Martin
Jay Duplass
Russell “Russ” Martin
Dichen Lachman
Lois Anthony
Arian Moayed
Frank
Karen Allen
Grandma Ruth Martin
Sean Kaufman
Kelvin
Adam Silver
Brian
Rosie Anne O’Gorman
Tube Kid
Alec Secăreanu
Ruiss

Jessica Chastain delivers the film’s most debated work in a twin role as Ursula Martin, a corporate executive whose emotional distance from her daughter seeds the family’s collapse, and as Other Mommy, the shape-shifting fiend wearing her likeness. Reviewers were unanimous in applauding her dedication, the Rotten Tomatoes consensus labelling it “a valiant turn” and The Guardian observing that “Chastain is clearly having fun” even as everything around her wobbles. Her ability to pivot between maternal frost and demonic threat is the picture’s keenest asset.

Arabella Olivia Clark turns in a startlingly grounded performance as seven-year-old Bela, the story’s emotional core. That a child actor should carry so much of a horror film’s weight is a real accomplishment, and critics remarked that her fear reads as genuine even when the scares around her do not. Jay Duplass supplies a weary, sympathetic presence as Russ, the stay-at-home father whose devotion to his daughter is the household’s one steady anchor. Dichen Lachman is commanding as Lois Anthony, the exorcist who attempts to intervene, while Arian Moayed appears as Frank, a family friend whose presence complicates every dynamic. Karen Allen lends gravitas to Grandma Ruth, whose clairvoyant gifts and hard-won wisdom about pain prove essential to Bela’s survival. Sean Kaufman, Adam Silver, Rosie Anne O’Gorman, and Alec Secăreanu complete the supporting ensemble.

Other Mommy Plot: The Demon That Asks Permission

The story turns on seven-year-old Isabela “Bela” Martin (Arabella Olivia Clark), a child struggling to find her footing at a new school while enduring the widening gulf between her parents. Her mother, Ursula (Jessica Chastain), is entirely consumed by her corporate ambitions, and her father, Russ (Jay Duplass), is an out-of-work stay-at-home dad who devotes himself almost wholly to Bela. Into this brittle home comes a supernatural presence bearing Ursula’s face—a thing Bela names “Other Mommy”—which repeatedly asks the child to let it into her heart.

One afternoon, Ursula arrives home from work without warning while Russ sleeps, ostensibly to share lunch with Bela. But something is wrong. Ursula’s gestures are stiff, her movements faintly off. When she asks to be let into Bela’s heart, Bela names her as Other Mommy. Russ wanders into the kitchen as burning food trips the smoke alarm and, glimpsing the entity folded impossibly beneath the counter, bolts from the house with Bela in tow. From there Other Mommy’s visitations escalate—it trails Bela past her bedroom, alters shape, and distorts its surroundings. At Russ and Ursula’s anniversary celebration it adopts the form of Bela’s babysitter Kelvin, appears to erase every guest from the room, raises Bela to the ceiling, and attempts to force its way inside her.

Realising they are in danger, the family retreats to the home of Ursula’s friend Frank. There Bela happens upon Ursula’s contact lens case, which leads Russ to suspect his wife of an affair. That night Other Mommy appears and, exploiting the household’s tension, manipulates Bela into wishing Frank out of their lives—then butchers him in front of them, shrugging off the bullets he fires in return. The family flees to a fast-food restaurant, but Other Mommy strikes once more, carrying Bela to a lake beneath a hilltop mansion where it swells to immense size and nearly crushes her, telling her that Ursula wishes she had never been born.

The family seeks shelter with Ursula’s estranged mother, Ruth (Karen Allen), who claims clairvoyant powers. Ruth takes them in and brings in paranormal investigators, who explain that demons gravitate toward children because of their innocence and identify Other Mommy as a trickster seeking to “carnate” into Bela and commandeer her life—something impossible without her consent. The team’s séance summons Other Mommy, but the investigators are powerless and are killed. The family escapes as the entity keeps menacing Bela. Resolved to stop running, they return home to confront it. Their weapons fail, forcing them to barricade themselves in the basement.

Hoping to end the siege, Ursula resolves to “destroy” Bela’s innocence and finally confesses that Bela’s real father is not Russ but Ursula’s first husband, whom she left for Russ. She then admits she never wanted to be a mother, but vows to Bela that she loves her regardless. The confession appears to weaken Other Mommy, yet it devastates Bela, who runs to her bedroom and begs the entity to enter her heart. Other Mommy appears and promises that Bela will never feel pain again. Recalling Ruth’s lesson that pain is unavoidable, Bela fights back, refusing the entity permission again and again until she defeats it. Months later, Bela, Ursula, and Russ happily string Christmas lights together, though Bela catches a despondent look on her mother’s face.

“Let me into your heart.”